Discrimination in suburbia

From race-baiting teens and humorous cultural disconnections to blunt pride and displacement

It's all about humility and restraint. First time Arab-American writer-director Cherien Dabis hops in the ever-deepening pool of immigrant displacement films to bring a kinder, gentler approach to her political and cultural messaging. By keeping the tone impish, the characters humane and the issues personal, Amreeka explores post-9/11 Arab anxieties and injustices without condemnation or proselytizing. In fact, Dabis smartly puts the focus on sisterhood and family while tackling the obstacles to assimilation and acceptance.

Palestinian single mom Muna (the engaging Nisreen Faour) moves to suburban Illinois with her teenage son Fadi (Melka Muallem) to be with her embittered sister Raghda's (Hiam Abbass) successful family. Set at the beginning of the Iraq War, it isn't long before the families are dealing with anti-Muslim discrimination, even though they aren't Muslim. And as you might expect, there are race-baiting teenagers, humorous cultural disconnections, blunt cultural pride and an ever-present sense of displacement. No one will accuse Amreeka of bucking the clichéd trends of the genre. 

Having said that, Dabis' film engages with its warm heart, likable leads and sly humor. In particular, there's a clever allusion to Israeli-Palestinian partition as Muna's young nieces divide their bedroom with tape. Never giving in to victimization or self-righteousness, Muna endures her marginalization and misfortunes with a fiercely open heart and mind. She may not always make the smartest decisions but her intentions are generous and true. Both Faour and Abbass bring a rich sense of identity and affection to their sister characters, making clear their strengths and flaws. Furthermore, Dabis roots her story firmly in the Arab immigrant experience, keeping a steady hand on their perspectives and attitudes.

But for all the depth and insight she grants her earthy Palestinian characters, Dabis falls into unfortunate cliché when it comes to non-Arabs, who are mostly depicted as bullies, insensitive dolts or naive but sympathetic outcasts. Between the blue-haired nerd Muna works with at White Castle, the well-meaning Jewish principal who tentatively begins to court her or the irrational high school thugs who torment her son, suburban America comes closer to resembling a sitcom than a complex and contradictory culture. It's a bummer misstep in a movie that seems so carefully crafted to be compassionate. 

Ultimately, Amreeka is too predictable to be great, too broad to be profound, but gentle, funny and conciliatory enough to check out and enjoy.

Opens Friday, Sept. 18, at the Landmark Maple Art Theatre, 4135 W. Maple Rd., Bloomfield Hills; 248-263-2111.

Jeff Meyers writes about film for Metro Times. Send comments to [email protected].

Scroll to read more Arts articles


Join Detroit Metro Times Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.