Harbaugh for Senate? The U-M coach could be just what the Michigan GOP needs

Don’t laugh — political interest seems to be a character trait

Jan 6, 2023 at 8:00 am
University of Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh. - Maize & Blue Nation, Wikimedia Creative Commons
Maize & Blue Nation, Wikimedia Creative Commons
University of Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh.

When Texas Christian University upset Michigan in the national college football semi-final on New Year’s Eve in the Fiesta Bowl, the TV camera showed Wolverines fans reacting with disbelief to Coach Jim Harbaugh’s timeout strategy as the seconds ticked away late in the fourth quarter.

One man jumped to his feet and shouted “Jim, what are you doing?” This wasn’t just any fan. He was Jack Harbaugh, Jim’s dad, a successful football coach in his own right. His question is one that echoes throughout much of Harbaugh’s career: Jim, what are you doing? And what might you do next?

As it turned out, those sideline decisions on timeouts weren’t as damaging as several other calls by Harbaugh in a 51-45 upset by the Horned Frogs. But that defeat hasn’t deterred Harbaugh’s annual case of itchy feet. Once again, he’s job-shopping around the National Football League.

Early tickles are coming from Denver and Carolina and there are likely to be more. Last year, Harbaugh got rejected by the Minnesota Vikings, but such things don’t discourage a man whose reach sometimes exceeds his grasp.

So here’s another possibility — perhaps tongue-in-cheek — for Harbaugh’s next job: He should run for the U.S. Senate seat from Michigan to replace the Democrat Debbie Stabenow, who announced Thursday that she will not be a candidate again in 2024.

Wait, don’t laugh.


  • The current senior senator from Alabama is Tommy Tuberville, a Republican who recently coached the football team at Auburn;

  • Harbaugh is not afraid to give his political opinions. Last autumn, for instance, Harbaugh voiced radio commercials against a woman’s right to choose abortion;

  • In Georgia’s Senate race, Herschel Walker proved that even a buffoon can get almost half the vote if he is a football celebrity;

  • By covering up a gun violation by one Wolverine player and minimizing anti-Semitic postings by another, Harbaugh has displayed the requisite cunning needed for the subterfuge of politics;

  • And by demanding swift and public punishment for Michigan State Spartans for a stadium tunnel beat-down at the Big House in Ann Arbor, Harbaugh displayed the brazen hypocrisy that boosts many political careers;

  • With Sports Illustrated reporting Thursday night that Michigan’s football program is under NCAA investigation, it might be the right time for Harbaugh to consider a new work environment;

  • On a more serious level: Although Harbaugh might not win a Senate race in Michigan against someone like, say, Democrat Jennifer Granholm (more on that below), he might help unify a state Republican Party even more fractious, petty, and grudge-driven than the current GOP is on the national level.

Of course, some right-wingers would question whether Harbaugh is a true Republican, at least in the MAGA sense. Perhaps Harbaugh would, too. He often comes off as a libertarian whose politics lurch from side to side.

He has supported Black Lives Matter, given a shout-out to Malcolm X, and shown a willingness to be open-minded to both liberal and conservative positions.

Although occasionally expressing admiration for Donald Trump and being called “the Donald Trump of College Football,” Harbaugh opposed Trump’s effort to cut legal aid to poor people.

When football players protested police violence by genuflecting on field during the national anthem, Trump called the players “sons of bitches” and said owners of teams should fire them.

Harbaugh thought differently.

“No, I don’t agree with the President,” he said in 2017. “Listen, that’s ridiculous. Check the Constitution.”

Political interest seems to be a character trait.

In a profile of Harbaugh that year, Politico magazine wrote that Harbaugh “sat down one-on-one with President Barack Obama, dropped in for meetings with half the Supreme Court and slipped into a rally on campus where Obama was stumping for Hillary Clinton.”

If Republicans were to recruit Harbaugh as a Senate candidate, Granholm would be a logical Democratic opponent. She served two terms as Michigan governor and has stayed visible and viable as Secretary of Energy under President Joe Biden.

The Great Lakes State has turned from red to blue in recent elections, thanks in part to popular constitutional amendments regarding marijuana and abortion rights.

Reaping the benefits have been liberal female Democrats like Governor Gretchen Whitmer, Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson, and Attorney General Dana Nessel. Granholm, at age 63, still has good years ahead of her.

This speculation about Harbaugh is not to endorse him or to suggest that every football celebrity would make a good candidate for U.S. Senator. Consider Walker, who last fall lost a regular election and a runoff to Ralph Warnock, the Democratic incumbent.

Reviewing the Walker campaign, the website Deadspin reported some of the things learned about the former star running back of the Georgia Bulldogs and the Dallas Cowboys.

“He terrorized his ex-wife, alienated the only son he acknowledged existence of — denigrating his looks and intelligence ... and was regarded as a shameless and obvious habitual liar to his own campaign staffers,” Deadspin wrote, adding, “He represented himself to be a born-again Christian, yet hid multiple children born out of wedlock.”

When discussing policy and issues, Walker assessed air pollution.

“Since we don’t control the air, our good air decides to float over to China’s bad air,” Walker said. “So, when China gets our good air, the bad air got to move. So it moves over to our good air space. Then, now, we’ve got to clean that back up.”

Despite exposing himself as a Trumpist bumpkin, Walker still won 48.63% of the vote in the runoff against 51.37% for Warnock.

Would Harbaugh as a candidate for a Michigan Senate seat be an improvement over Walker in Georgia? Of course. He’s glib and better at dodging dodgy questions. But he might have to answer for stuff that he has thus far fudged. For instance:

Harbaugh played football for Michigan from 1983 through 1986. His father was an assistant coach for seven years there in the 1970s. In all those years, U-M physician Dr. Robert Anderson molested football players during routine physical examinations.

Players from that era have said Anderson’s misdeeds were common knowledge. But in 2021, Harbaugh seemed to exonerate Dr. Anderson, who was also the family doctor.

“Never saw, never anything inappropriate,” Harbaugh said. “Nor did I ever hear anything that was inappropriate about Dr. Anderson.” Harbaugh added that he “never experienced anything inappropriate.”

Harbaugh in those years was an astute young quarterback and the son of a veteran coach. How could young Harbaugh stay blissfully unaware of a sexual predator in the football program? Come to think of it, maybe father Jack Harbaugh could deal with pointed questions beyond “Jim, what are you doing?”

Coming soon: Metro Times Daily newsletter. We’ll send you a handful of interesting Detroit stories every morning. Subscribe now to not miss a thing.

Follow us: Google News | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Facebook | Twitter